The very nature of public policy and natural resource management involves conflict, and often the parties involved in such disagreements are not only distrustful of one another, they can be distrustful of any “third party” mediator or facilitator that is brought in as an “impartial” agent to help find solutions and outcomes to the dispute. In addition, when an agency or governmental entity is the sponsor of a third party neutral, other participants in the dispute can be suspicious that the agency may have undue influence over the facilitator or mediator.
Fishing the Skeena--a Cautionary Tale
Like many steelhead anglers, I’m susceptible to dreams of landing a 20-pound steelhead on a fly. Hooking into one of these ocean cruisers on a fly rod connects an angler to a force majeure that sucks the wind out of most mortals. In conversations about which rivers offer the best chances of hooking into such a steelhead, invariably the name “Skeena” gets mentioned.
Known for 15- to 30-pounders that will take a fly, talk of the Skeena River in northern British Columbia solicits a misty-eyed glint from many anglers. When my fishing buddy, David Bayles, suggested recently that we head to the Skeena River to chase steelhead with flies and Spey rods, however, I thought he was joking.
Photo Credit: Derek Barber
Hunting Big Trout in Patagonia
Rapido!!” Diego, our guide on the Alumine River in Patagonia, muttered behind me.
“Again?” I squawked. We had been stalking large trout with dry flies in the eddies and slow waters of the river, and once again I had pulled the “Bicho Feo” — the ugly bug imitation I was using — out of the mouth of the rainbow instead of setting the barbless hook.
I’d been fishing the Alumine for three days, and while I had landed some of the river’s big trout, I had experienced more whiffs than hookups — even though fish were on the bite.
Photo Credit: Mark Reusser
“OK, you’re up,” I called to my wife in the front of our drift boat. We had just rigged up after lunch on our first day of a six-day fishing trip down the Middle Fork of the Salmon River in Idaho. And Gretchen, fly rod in hand, was eager to test her skills catching native cutthroat trout on a dry fly.
But shortly after she made a few casts I yelled, “Better sit down!” The river had pushed us out of the fishing pocket and into another rapids.
Photo Credit: Gretchen Matsuoka
In 1916, a simple dictum regulated trout fishing for the entire McKenzie River Basin: “75 trout per day. Bait allowed.”
Since then, conditions have changed in the McKenzie watershed: more people live here, more demands are placed on the river from multiple users, and our understanding of native trout as part of a complex ecological system has evolved.
Photo Credit: Ethan Nickels Outfitters
Watershed Initiatives provides effective, informed leadership solutions for agencies, local governments, and multi-stakeholder forums to:
- improve decision-making and problem-solving skills
- define project outcomes and create pathways to achieve them
- assess organizational needs and abilities
- turn technical information into language accessible to a broad audience
Photo Credit: T. Charles Dewberry
In May I moderated a panel on the island of Eleuthera (one of the outer islands in The Bahamas) focused on tourism and development issues. The panel was part of a day-long conference that the Cape Eleuthera Institute and a private school had convened to bring government officials, NGOs, local residents, and other concerned people together to become educated about, explore ideas for, a more sustainable tourism industry that would be beneficial to the ecology and economy of Eleuthera. This conference was created partly in response to the numerous failed Club Med-style developments that littered the beaches and landscape along Eleuthera's 110 miles of coastline.
Clients and Publications
Watershed Initiatives' clients have included federal, state and local agencies, public interest groups and local communitiy stakeholder groups. WI helps clients resolve contentious public policy and natural resource disputes, and helps clients develop restoration and management plans that garner a broad base of support.
WI has published and edited numerous articles, manuals and other materials that address natural resource management, usage and restoration issues. To review these materials, please click "Read More."
About Watershed Initiatives, LLC
Watershed Initiatives, LLC provides procedural, organizational, and editorial support for groups, science teams, government agencies and stakeholder representatives involved in natural resource management and planning. Paul Hoobyar, principal at WI, is a trained mediator/facilitator specializing in natural resource issues. Paul is registered with the U.S. Institute for Environmental Conflict Resolution and the Oregon Department of Justice Appropriate Dispute Resolution (ADR) Roster of Mediatior and Facilitators.
Photo Credit: Tim O'Dell